I don't search out slabbed cards very often -- particularly for newer releases -- but when one presents itself and the slabbing has not increased the price I have to pay, I don't mind adding it to my collection. Certain releases don't give you the choice, and In The Game is one of the prime examples of cards hitting the market pre-slabbed. My latest Ryan Getzlaf pickup hails from such an ITG release.
Out of 2008-2009 In The Game Ultimate Memorabilia 9th Edition comes this sweet piece of a glove used by The Captain. It's numbered 23/24 (the silver parallel) and serves as my first piece of a game-used glove. It set me back $6.74 shipped.