Ticket Monster LAD Banner

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Matt Kemp, Your Real 2011 National League MVP

Because, you know, he was the best player in the NL this season. And if you're the best player, and have the best season, you provide the most value to your team. You know there's a serious disconnect and major issues with who gets to vote when most of the voters begin their explanation with "Matt Kemp was the best player, but....". There is no but; the award is for the best - and hence the most valuable - player. Simple. This is quickly heading off into the realm of ridiculous Bill Plaschke logic (and even The Argyled One picked Kemp, though he used traditional statistics in the process of coming to the correct conclusion). Ryan Braun had a great, great season. Matt Kemp had a phenomenal season.


I did a wee bit of analysis a while back showing why Kemp was the proper choice, but I'm not really all that surprised by the voting. Apparently, who your teammates are is an appropriate and major factor in winning the award. Could have fooled me....it's an individual award based on individual performance. At least, that's what intelligent voters understand. Hell, even the BBWAA guidelines stipulate a team's performance does not matter.


Anyways, congrats to Ryan Braun, who at least is a more than worthy candidate and was second in the real world where you don't get penalized for having terrible teammates. The biggest travesty though is that Ryan Howard got a fourth place vote and three fifth place votes en route to finishing in the top ten. Talk about crazy. Oh, and that beautiful Kemp at the top was an eBay score, for less than the price of a blaster. Picked it up many moons ago. A great addition to my Kemp PC, and easily one of my favorite cards - Kemp or otherwise - in my collection. It's my seventh Kemp autograph, and second of the on-card variety.

5 comments:

Spiegel83 said...

Kemp is more deserving. I don't even think it is my Doyer bias kickng in.

mmmrhubarb said...

I can't agree with you, for fear of alienating my Brewers trading partners.

(you're right, though)

camclow said...

Kemp was the best player this season. I wonder him not getting the award has anything to do with Kershaw getting the CY. Wonder if they felt weird about giving a non playoff team both awards. Great season by both players though.

Greg Zakwin said...

Spiegel- Indeed. Objective analysis shows it's Kemp.

Rhubarb- haha ;)

Cam- I would hope voters didn't think that way, but I wouldn't be shocked.

Kemptakesevery otheryearoff said...

news flash: the award is for the "most valuable player" and not "guy with the best stats" award.

ps: braun had TWICE as many first place votes as kemp.